Who would win questions for kids: 60 match-ups to argue at dinner

Kids love a good "who would win?" argument, and it's brilliant practice at giving reasons. Every match-up below is a contest, not a fight: a race, a talent show, a baking competition. Pick one, choose a champion and defend it with an opinion, a reason and an example.

How to play defend your champion at the dinner table

  1. Pick a match-up from the lists below, or let each player choose a champion they love: an animal, a hero, a food, even a favourite toy.
  2. Each player takes a side. If two people want the same champion, one of them gets to choose the contest instead.
  3. Take turns defending your champion with an opinion, a reason and an example.
  4. The other side can ask one "But what about…?" question.
  5. A judge (the youngest player makes a good one) picks the most convincing argument, and has to give a reason too.

How to argue like a champion: opinion, reason, example

Every good argument has the same three parts:

  • Opinion: say who wins. "The octopus would win at hide-and-seek."
  • Reason: say why, starting with "because". "Because it can change colour to match the rocks."
  • Example: help the others picture it. "If it hid in a rock pool, you'd look straight at it and see nothing."

Older kids can add a fourth step and answer the other side: "Some people think the chameleon would win, but it can't hide underwater."

Animal match-ups

  • Who would win at hide-and-seek: an octopus or a chameleon?
  • Who would win a high-jump contest: a kangaroo or a frog?
  • Who would win a staring contest: an owl or a cat?
  • Who would win a singing competition: a blackbird or a humpback whale?
  • Who would be first to the top of a tree: a squirrel or a monkey?
  • Who would build the best house: a beaver or a bird?
  • Who would win a swimming race across a pond: a duck or a dog?
  • Who would win a tidying-up contest: a colony of ants or a family of raccoons?
  • Who would win a game of tag: a cheetah or a hare?
  • Who would be the napping champion: a sloth or a koala?

Hero match-ups

  • Who would win a baking contest: a knight or a pirate?
  • Who would get to the moon first: an astronaut or a dragon?
  • Who would be the better teacher for a day: a wizard or a robot?
  • Who would win a dance-off: a T. rex or a friendly giant?
  • Who would make the best football captain: a superhero who can fly or one who is super strong?
  • Who would build the best sandcastle: a mermaid or a sea captain?
  • Who would win a game of chess: an alien or a very old tortoise?
  • Who would be better at looking after a baby dragon: a princess or a fairy?
  • Who would win a talent show: a singing robot or a juggling elf?
  • Who would be best at finding lost things: a detective or a dog with a super nose?

Food debates: which is best?

  • Which is the best pizza topping: mushrooms or sweetcorn?
  • Which is the king of breakfast: pancakes or toast?
  • Which is crispier and better: chips or roast potatoes?
  • Which is the best way to eat an egg: boiled, scrambled or fried?
  • Which is the best ice cream flavour: mint or vanilla?
  • Which is the best sandwich filling: cheese or jam?
  • Which is the best vegetable on the plate: carrots or peas?
  • Which is better for dipping: bread in soup or apple slices in yoghurt?
  • Which would be the better birthday cake: a chocolate cake or a tower of cupcakes?
  • Which food would make the best superhero: a brave broccoli or a speedy spaghetti?

Sports and games match-ups

  • Who would be the better goalkeeper: a goalie with eight arms or a robot on springs?
  • Which team would win a tug of war: a thousand ants or one elephant?
  • Which is the best playground game: tag or hide-and-seek?
  • Which is the hardest sport to learn: gymnastics or rock climbing?
  • Which sport would a cat be best at, and which would it be worst at?
  • Which is the best sports day race: the sack race or the egg-and-spoon race?
  • Which ball is the most fun: a beach ball, a football or a bouncy ball?
  • Which is more fun: playing a sport or watching one?
  • Which is the best sport for a rainy day: football in the mud or swimming indoors?
  • Which is better: being part of a team or competing on your own?

Everyday object showdowns

  • Which is more useful: a spoon or a fork?
  • Which would win a race down a slide: a teddy bear or a toy car?
  • Which is the greatest invention: the bed or the wheel?
  • Which is more useful on a desert island: a pillow or a torch?
  • Which is the best present: a book or a ball?
  • Which is cosier: a hoodie or a blanket?
  • Which would make the better pet: a houseplant or a pet rock?
  • Which is the most important thing in a kitchen: the fridge or the oven?
  • Which makes the best den: cushions or cardboard boxes?
  • Which is the best way to get to school: walking, cycling or scooting?

Big debates for older kids (8 to 11)

No silly contest here: these ones need a real argument.

  • Which is better: the long summer holidays or the first snow of winter?
  • Which superpower would help the most people: flying or healing?
  • Which matters more: being clever or being kind?
  • Which was the better time to be a kid: now, or when your parents were young?
  • Which is the best place to live: a lighthouse or a treehouse?
  • Which is better: the book or the film of the book?
  • Which is the best age to be: 8 or 80?
  • Which is more useful to learn: cooking or swimming?
  • Which is better for a birthday: a big party or a sleepover with one friend?
  • Which is the best season of the year, and can you defend it for a whole minute?

Tips for a fair contest

  • Keep it a contest, not a fight. Races, talent shows and bake-offs are funnier, and nobody's favourite gets hurt.
  • Reward the best reason, not the loudest voice. The judge has to say which argument convinced them, and why.
  • Switch sides for one round. Defending the champion you didn't pick is harder, and it's the best practice of all.
  • Check the facts after dinner. Some match-ups have a real answer, so look it up together later and see whose argument came closest.
  • Adapt by age. Ages 4 to 6 just need an opinion and a "because"; ages 7 to 9 add an example; ages 10 and up answer the other side.

For more debating at the table, try Family debate club, Switch sides for teens, or the habit Give your opinion.

Frequently asked questions

What are good who would win questions for kids?

Good who would win questions turn two things kids love into a fun contest rather than a fight: an octopus and a chameleon at hide-and-seek, a knight and a pirate in a baking contest, a T. rex and a giant in a dance-off. Ask for a reason with every answer.

How do you teach kids to give reasons for their opinions?

Use three steps: say your opinion, give a reason that starts with "because", then add an example. Practising with silly match-ups is easier than starting with serious topics, and the same three steps work for both.

What is the opinion, reason, example structure?

It's a simple way to build an argument: first you say what you think (opinion), then why (reason), then you show it with a real or imagined case (example). Older children can add a fourth step by answering the other side.

Play it with Kalmdix

Each player picks a hero they love: a sports star, a game character, a dinosaur… Kalmdix explains the game, gives turns by name and leads three short rounds at your pace. Skill practised: Arguing: opinion, reason, example. Put your phone on the table and tap Start. Plans from €9.99 a month.

More games for kids

Games · Habits · Blog · Pricing · Sign in

Terms · Privacy