Most arguments go wrong because each person is busy preparing their reply. In this active listening game, you are not allowed to answer until you have rephrased the other person's point to their satisfaction. Here is how to play, with 50 light topics to practise on.
How to play change my mind at the dinner table
- Someone picks a topic and states their opinion with one reason: "Change my mind: breakfast should be savoury, because sweet things in the morning never keep me going."
- A challenger wants to argue back, but first they must rephrase the opinion and the reason, until the first player says "Yes, that's it."
- Only then does the challenger give their counter-argument, in under a minute.
- Before replying, the first player rephrases the challenge in the same way.
- After two or three exchanges, the first player says how far they moved: not at all, a little, or completely. The challenger picks the next topic.
Nobody has to change their mind. The game is won by the person who rephrased most accurately, not by the person who argued loudest.
The listening steps: repeat, check, then answer
- Repeat the other person's point in your own words, including their reason: "So you think a savoury breakfast wins because it keeps you going for longer."
- Check that you got it right: "Is that it?" If they say "Not quite", try again until they agree.
- Answer with your own view, and only now: "I see it differently, because pancakes are the only reason I get out of bed."
It feels slow the first few times. That's normal: you are breaking the habit of planning your reply while the other person is still talking.
What a round sounds like
Teen: "Change my mind: clocks should always be set five minutes fast, because then you're never late."
Parent: "So your point is that the fake five minutes gives you a safety net. Is that it?"
Teen: "Not quite. It's that it tricks my brain into hurrying."
Parent: "Got it: it's about tricking yourself into moving faster. Then here's my problem: after a week, your brain knows the trick and ignores it."
Notice that the first rephrase missed, and that was fine. The correction is often where the real reason comes out.
Food opinions to practise on
- Brussels sprouts deserve a second chance.
- Breakfast should be savoury, not sweet.
- A meal isn't complete without bread on the table.
- Homemade burgers beat any restaurant burger.
- Spicy food is worth the tears.
- Picnics are overrated: the ground is lumpy and the food gets warm.
- Plain pasta with butter is a perfect dinner.
- Mixing all your food together on the plate is the best way to eat it.
- Crunchy food beats soft food every time.
- Fizzy water is just water that's trying too hard.
Everyday life topics
- Walking is the best way to get anywhere less than half an hour away.
- Lists make life easier, even for fun things.
- Unloading the dishwasher is the worst chore in the house.
- Silence on a car journey is better than music.
- Packing at the last minute is a skill, not a problem.
- Weekends are better spent at home than out.
- The best seat on the sofa belongs to whoever got there first.
- Birthdays are more fun for the guests than for the birthday person.
- Time spent waiting in a queue is not wasted time.
- Clocks should always be set five minutes fast.
School, sport and hobby topics
- Art is just as important as maths.
- Anyone can learn to draw.
- Every hobby is better with friends.
- Collecting things is a proper hobby.
- Reading the last page first is a perfectly good way to read a book.
- Cycling is the best way to explore a new place.
- Cheering from the side is harder than playing.
- A hobby you're bad at is still worth doing.
- The summer holidays are too long.
- Every sport is more fun with mixed-age teams.
Silly but surprisingly divisive topics
- A hot dog is a sandwich.
- Penguins are the funniest animal on the planet.
- Ducks are secretly the cleverest birds.
- Wearing socks in bed is a great idea.
- Staying in pyjamas all weekend is the sign of a good weekend.
- The middle seat in the car is the best seat.
- Owls only look wise.
- Jigsaw puzzles should be done without looking at the box.
- Lowercase letters are friendlier than capitals.
- Bubble wrap is more fun than the present inside it.
Change my mind topics for teens and adults
- Spoilers don't ruin a good story.
- Live music beats recorded music every time.
- Planning a trip is more fun than the trip itself.
- It's fine to stop reading a book you're not enjoying.
- Black-and-white films are worth watching.
- Everyone should try one completely new hobby every year.
- A good friend should tell you when you're wrong.
- First impressions are usually wrong.
- Small talk is underrated.
- An experience makes a better present than an object.
Listening phrases to use
- "So what you're saying is…"
- "If I've understood, you think… because…"
- "Is that it, or did I miss something?"
- "Which reason is the big one for you?"
- "Let me check I've got your reason right."
- "I can see why that matters to you."
- "Can you say more about why…?"
- "What would make you a little less sure?"
- "Fair point. Here's where I see it differently:"
- "Did I put it better or worse than you did?"
Tips for parents
- Go second. Let your teen state an opinion first and rephrase it before you say anything: it shows the game is fair.
- Rephrase generously. Try to put their argument even better than they did. It's disarming, and it's the whole skill.
- Keep real conflicts out of it at first. Start with sprouts, not curfews; once the habit is there, it helps with harder conversations.
- Admit when you move. "I'm a bit less sure now" shows that changing your mind is a strength, not a defeat.
- Adapt by age. Children of 8 to 11 can rephrase in one sentence starting "You think…"; teens can be asked to rephrase the reason, not just the opinion.
To keep practising, try The dinner of opinions or Switch sides, or read more about how to really listen.
Frequently asked questions
What are some active listening games for teens?
Change my mind is a simple one: someone states a light opinion, and anyone who wants to argue must first rephrase it until the speaker agrees. Retelling a story you've just heard, or asking two questions before replying, also work well at the dinner table.
How do you practise active listening at home?
Pick low-stakes topics, like whether breakfast should be savoury, and follow three steps: repeat what you heard, check you got it right, then answer. Practising on light topics makes it easier to do the same when a conversation really matters.
What are examples of active listening phrases?
Useful phrases include "So what you're saying is…", "Did I get that right?" and "Which reason is the big one for you?". They show you heard the other person before you give your own view.