This or that questions are the quickest way to get a whole table talking: two options, one pick, no wrong answer. Here are 100 light ones for every age, sorted by theme, plus a simple twist that turns quick answers into real listening.
How to play this or that at the dinner table
- One person reads a pair out loud, for example "Pancakes or waffles?"
- On the count of three, everyone says their pick at the same time. No "both" and no "it depends".
- Go round the table: each person gives one reason, in one sentence.
- Before giving your own reason, repeat the reason of the person who spoke just before you, in your own words. They nod, or they correct you.
- The reader hands over to the next person, who chooses a pair from a different theme.
On a busy evening, skip the reasons and just call out your picks. You will still learn something: who knew a parent was secretly a night owl?
The twist: repeat the reason before you answer
Most this or that games are over in seconds: two answers, a laugh, next question. The dinner of opinions slows it down by one small step. Before anyone gives their own reason, they say back the reason they just heard:
"Waffles, because the little squares keep the syrup in place."
"So for you it's about the syrup not running off the plate. Right? I'm pancakes, because you can stack them into a tower."
It sounds tiny, but it changes the table. People listen to the end of each other's sentences, because they know they will have to repeat them. And disagreeing about something as harmless as waffles is gentle practice for disagreeing kindly about things that matter more. Handy ways to start the repeat:
- "So you picked it because…"
- "If I heard you right, the best part for you is…"
- "Your reason was… Did I get that?"
Food this or that questions
- Pancakes or waffles?
- Crunchy or smooth peanut butter?
- Pineapple on pizza: yes or absolutely not?
- Jam or honey on toast?
- Hot chocolate with marshmallows or without?
- Strawberries or blueberries?
- Long pasta or short pasta?
- Cereal first or milk first?
- Sandwich crusts on or off?
- Popcorn or crisps on film night?
- Eat the best bit first or save it for last?
- Thin crispy pizza or thick fluffy pizza?
- Ice cream in a cone or in a bowl?
- Milk chocolate or dark chocolate?
- Porridge or cereal?
- Ketchup or mayonnaise with chips?
Holiday and weekend this or that questions
- Swimming pool or the sea?
- Road trip or train journey?
- Sandcastles or rock pools?
- A hot, sunny holiday or a snowy one?
- Plan every day or decide each morning?
- Sleep in or get up early for an adventure?
- Window seat or aisle seat?
- Pack the night before or on the morning?
- A silly souvenir or a useful one?
- Somewhere new or a favourite place again?
- Pyjama day or day trip?
- Museum or theme park?
- Tent or caravan?
- Photos of everything or no photos at all?
Animal and nature this or that questions
- Cats or dogs?
- Penguins or polar bears?
- Butterflies or ladybirds?
- Hamster or goldfish?
- Rabbits or guinea pigs?
- Hedgehogs or squirrels?
- Owls or parrots?
- A day at the farm or a day at the aquarium?
- Watching clouds or watching stars?
- Grow flowers or grow vegetables?
- Forest path or beach walk?
- Lions or tigers?
- Sunrise or sunset?
- Horses or donkeys?
Seasons and weather this or that questions
- Summer or winter?
- Spring or autumn?
- Sun hat or woolly hat?
- Jumping in puddles or kicking up leaves?
- Building a snowman or making snow angels?
- Long summer evenings or cosy winter nights?
- Scarf or gloves?
- Sledging or ice skating?
- An ice lolly on a hot day or soup on a cold one?
- A bright frosty morning or a warm drizzly afternoon?
- Wellies or sandals?
- Umbrella or hooded raincoat?
- A windy day or a foggy day?
- Barbecue weather or blanket weather?
Everyday habits this or that questions
- Early bird or night owl?
- Shower or bath?
- Socks or bare feet at home?
- Music while you work or total quiet?
- Paper books or audiobooks?
- Plan ahead or go with the flow?
- Tidy as you go or one big tidy-up at the end?
- Shoes off at the door or shoes on inside?
- Pen or pencil?
- Message or phone call?
- Alarm clock or wake up on your own?
- Big breakfast or quick breakfast?
- Bedroom door open or closed at night?
- Hardest job first or easiest job first?
- Sing in the shower or sing in the car?
Silly this or that questions
- Robots or dinosaurs?
- Pirates or astronauts?
- Superhero cape or wizard hat?
- Unicorns or mermaids?
- Bubbles or balloons?
- A talking toaster or a singing fridge?
- Knock-knock jokes or tongue-twisters?
- Spots or stripes?
- Squeaky shoes or shoes that light up?
- Rubber duck or rubber chicken?
- A pet called Captain Noodle or one called Sir Wobbles?
- A secret door behind the bookcase or a trapdoor under the rug?
- A teddy bigger than you or one that fits in your pocket?
Bigger this or that questions for teens and adults
Same game, slightly more to think about. These work well once the younger ones have left the table.
- Ask for directions or work it out yourself?
- Give advice or ask for advice?
- Lead the team or be the reliable helper?
- Know the plan or be surprised?
- Talk it out now or sleep on it?
- One big trip or lots of small ones?
- Learn by reading or learn by doing?
- Write it down or keep it in your head?
- Blunt feedback or gentle feedback?
- Group chat or one-to-one?
- Finish everything you start or know when to stop?
- Lend your things easily or keep them to yourself?
- Made-up stories or true stories?
- Learn one thing deeply or lots of things a little?
Tips for a good dinner of opinions
- Let the youngest pick first. Their answer won't be swayed by the older ones, and hearing their reason repeated back makes them feel listened to.
- Correct a repeat gently. "Nearly! It's more about the crunch" keeps it light, and the person repeating gets a second go.
- Ask one "really?" question. When someone picks something surprising, one curious follow-up ("What's wrong with rock pools?") turns a pick into a story.
- Jump between themes. Going from food to weather to silly keeps teens interested and stops it feeling like a quiz.
- Try the majority guess with older kids. Before answering, everyone guesses what most of the table will choose, then you count.
- Celebrate surprises, not right answers. The fun is discovering how different your tastes are, not deciding who is right about pineapple.
For more ways to keep dinner talk going, see our conversation starters for family dinner, or try Would you rather… and why? and Change my mind.
Frequently asked questions
What are good this or that questions for families?
Good this or that questions are quick, light and have no right answer: food, holidays, animals, seasons and everyday habits work for every age. Keep the trickier ones, like blunt or gentle feedback, for teens and adults.
How do you play this or that at dinner?
Someone reads two options, everyone picks one on the count of three, then each person gives a one-sentence reason. To make it a listening game, each player repeats the previous person's reason before giving their own.
What is the difference between this or that and would you rather?
This or that asks about everyday preferences, like pancakes or waffles, so it is quick and easy for young children. Would you rather offers imaginary or extreme choices, which take longer to answer but often lead to bigger stories.