Teenagers love a dilemma, because there is no answer to memorise and their reasoning counts as much as an adult's. These 45 everyday moral dilemmas are short enough to read out between two mouthfuls, and the follow-up questions turn a quick "I'd do this" into a real conversation about why.
How to play the dilemma game at the dinner table
- One person reads a dilemma aloud, or invents one from their own week (changing the names).
- Everyone takes ten seconds to decide what they would do, without saying it yet.
- On "three, two, one", everyone answers at once: thumbs up for the first choice, thumbs down for the second, or a flat hand for "a third way".
- Each person gives one reason. The youngest goes first, so nobody simply copies a parent.
- Someone asks one follow-up question (see the list further down), and anyone can change their answer if they have been persuaded.
There is no score and no right answer handed down by the grown-ups. The point is to hear how everyone at the table weighs loyalty, honesty and fairness, and to notice when those values pull in different directions.
Friendship dilemmas
- Your best friend proudly plays you a song they wrote and asks what you honestly think. You find it pretty weak. What do you say?
- Two friends have birthday parties on the same Saturday afternoon. One is your oldest friend; the other just moved to your school and knows almost nobody. Which do you go to?
- A friend told you a secret. Another friend asks you straight out whether it is true. What do you answer?
- You and a friend joined a club together. They want to quit and would like you to quit too, but you love it.
- A new pupil sits alone at lunch every day. Your friends don't want to invite them over. Do you go and sit with them anyway?
- A friend borrowed your favourite hoodie a month ago and seems to have forgotten. Do you ask for it back, or let it go?
- You are invited to a sleepover, but your best friend isn't. They would be hurt if they found out. Do you go?
- Your friend keeps cancelling plans at the last minute. Do you tell them it bothers you, or stop inviting them?
Honesty dilemmas
- You find a wallet on the pavement with cash and a library card inside. What exactly do you do with it?
- A cashier gives you too much change, and the shop is about to close. Do you go back in?
- Your younger brother broke a mug and a parent thinks it was the dog. Do you say anything?
- A relative gives you a jumper you really don't like and asks if you love it.
- You scratch a neighbour's car with your bike. Nobody saw. Do you knock on their door?
- A teacher's marking mistake gives you a better grade than you earned. Do you point it out?
- A friend asks if you can tell their parents they were at your house when they were somewhere else, somewhere harmless. Do you agree?
Fairness dilemmas
- You are team captain. Do you pick your best friend, who is an average player, or the strongest player, who is often unkind?
- Your group wins a prize for a project, but one member did almost nothing. Should they get an equal share of the prize?
- Your team wins because the referee missed a foul by one of your players. Do you say something?
- There is one slice of cake left. You helped bake it, but your sister hasn't had any yet. Who should get it?
- A younger cousin is losing a board game badly and starting to cry. Do you let them win?
- Your younger sister is allowed things you were never allowed at her age. Do you complain, or let it go?
- You find out a friend got into a club because their aunt runs it, ahead of someone who tried harder. Do you say anything?
School dilemmas
- Minutes before class, a friend asks to look at your homework "just to check one answer". You suspect they want to copy it.
- You notice a classmate reading answers off their hand during a test.
- In a group project, one person's part is so weak it will drag down everyone's mark. Do you quietly redo it?
- The teacher leaves the answer sheet on the desk during break and walks out.
- Someone in your class is being laughed at for their accent. You don't know them well. Do you step in?
- You are asked to vote for class representative. Your friend is running, but you think another candidate would do a better job.
- You forgot to do your part of a project. Do you admit it, or blame a computer problem?
Online life dilemmas
- A friend posts a photo of you mid-sneeze. Everyone finds it hilarious, except you. Do you ask them to take it down?
- Your group chat starts joking about someone who isn't in it. Do you join in, stay quiet or say something?
- You see a post that seems untrue, but it supports something you agree with. Do you share it?
- A friend's game account is still logged in on your console. Do you tell them, or log them out without a word?
- Your friend asks you to like and share their new video. You think it's boring. Do you do it anyway?
- An idea you had gets posted by a friend as their own, and people love it. Do you say it was yours?
- A classmate posts something unkind about a teacher. You think it's funny, but unfair. Do you react?
Home and everyday dilemmas
- You promised to help a parent on Saturday morning, then friends invite you somewhere amazing at the same time.
- A shop is giving out free samples. The sign says "one each". Nobody is watching. Do you take two?
- You are eating at a friend's house and the meal is something you really dislike. Do you eat it, leave it or say something?
- You see a younger child being teased at the bus stop by kids your age. What do you do?
- Your parent asks whether you've finished your homework. You've done most of it. What do you answer?
- You are the last to leave a club room and notice the lights and heating are still on. It's not your job to switch them off.
- Your grandparent tells the same story for the fifth time. Do you tell them you've heard it?
Thought-experiment dilemmas for older teens
- You could know your exam results a month early, but you couldn't change them. Would you look?
- A machine could make you always feel happy, but you could never leave it. Would you plug in?
- You can keep one: every memory of the past year, or the chance to redo one day of it.
- You could read your friends' thoughts for a day without them knowing. Would you?
Follow-up questions that make dilemmas better
- "Would your answer change if nobody could ever find out?"
- "What if it were your best friend instead of a stranger?"
- "What would you advise your younger brother or sister to do?"
- "Is there a third option nobody has mentioned?"
- "How would each person in the story feel about your choice?"
- "Would you be comfortable telling the whole family what you did?"
Tips for talking about dilemmas with teens
- Hold back your own answer. If a parent answers first, many teens either copy it or argue against it on principle. Go last.
- Don't turn it into a lesson. If a teen picks the answer you dislike, ask about their reasons with curiosity rather than correcting them.
- Praise good reasoning, not the "right" answer. "That's a clever reason" lands better than "good choice".
- Let them invent dilemmas. Their own scenarios show you what is really on their mind, often more than a direct question would.
- Adapt for younger siblings. Under-10s can join with the home and fairness dilemmas, which are concrete and easy to imagine.
For more games that stretch reasoning, try Switch sides, where everyone argues the opposite view, or Family debate club, and see our habit on how to respect opinions you don't share.
Frequently asked questions
What are good moral dilemmas for teenagers?
The best ones come from everyday life: a friend asking to copy homework, finding a wallet, a group chat turning on someone. They feel real, there is no obvious answer, and teens can explain their reasoning without being judged.
How do you discuss moral dilemmas with teens without lecturing?
Let everyone answer at the same time, ask the teen for their reasons before giving yours, and accept that reasonable people can choose differently. Follow-up questions work better than corrections.
Is there a right answer to a moral dilemma?
Usually not a single one: a dilemma is a situation where two good values, like loyalty and honesty, pull in different directions. The useful part is explaining which value you put first and why.