Problem solving is much easier to practise on a squirrel raiding the bird feeder than in the middle of a real upset. Here are 48 problem solving scenarios for kids, from silly to serious, and a four-step method the whole family can use at dinner.
How to play problem squad at the dinner table
- One player picks a problem from the lists below, or brings a real one from their day.
- They describe it in one or two sentences, like a case for the squad: "My problem is…"
- Everyone suggests one idea. At this stage, no idea is too silly.
- The player who brought the problem picks the idea they like best, and says why.
- At the next meal, ask the most important question: did it work?
The 4-step problem solving method
These four steps work for a lost sock and for a falling-out with a friend.
- Say the problem in one sentence. "My shoes are never by the door in the morning." If it takes a whole speech, it's probably two problems.
- Find three ideas. Silly ones are welcome: "a robot shoe butler" can lead to "a basket by the door".
- Choose with three checks. Does it solve the problem? Is it kind to everyone? Can we actually do it?
- Try it and check back. Agree on a day to ask "Did it work?" If it didn't, go back to step 2.
Here is the method on a real case. The problem: "I forget my PE kit." Three ideas: a note on the front door, packing the kit straight after it's washed, or a robot that shouts "PE!" every Tuesday. The robot fails check three, so the squad picks packing the kit after washing, because it happens without anyone having to remember. A week later: two PE days out of two, kit in the bag.
Funny problems to warm up
- The cat keeps falling asleep on the warm laptop, so nobody can use it.
- Every time we sing in the car, the dog howls along louder than us.
- A squirrel keeps stealing all the food from the bird feeder.
- Grandad keeps losing his glasses, and they're usually on top of his head.
- The goldfish looks bored. How could we make its day more interesting?
- A pigeon has decided that our windowsill is its new home.
- Odd socks keep vanishing in the wash, and the sock drawer is full of lonely ones.
- Someone keeps putting the empty milk carton back in the fridge.
- Teddy keeps falling out of bed in the middle of the night.
- The ice lollies always melt before we get them home from the shop.
Everyday problems at home
- Shoes pile up by the front door and everyone trips over them.
- Getting out of the house in the morning always takes too long.
- The toy box is so full that the lid won't shut.
- Two brothers both want to choose the film on Friday night.
- Nobody can remember whose turn it is to feed the fish.
- Everyone needs the bathroom at exactly the same time in the morning.
- Tiny building bricks keep ending up under bare feet.
- A little sister keeps coming into her big sister's room without knocking.
- The TV remote disappears at least once a day.
- Homework always gets remembered on Sunday night, never on Saturday morning.
School and friendship problems
- I keep forgetting my PE kit on PE day.
- My friend and I both want to be captain of the team.
- A new boy in class doesn't speak much English yet, and he looks lost at break.
- Someone keeps copying my drawings and saying they did them first.
- Two of my friends have fallen out, and I'm stuck in the middle.
- My reading book is boring, but I'm supposed to finish it.
- I want to join the football game at break, but the teams are already picked.
- I said something unkind to a friend, and now they won't talk to me.
- My best friend is moving to another town next month.
- I know the answer, but I feel too shy to put my hand up.
Bigger problems for older kids (9 to 11)
These need more than one idea, and sometimes a plan with several steps.
- I've got three things to do on Saturday and only enough time for two.
- Our class has to agree on a name for the class pet, and there are thirty different ideas.
- The little park near school is always covered in litter.
- One person in my group project isn't doing their share of the work.
- I'd love a pet, but someone in the family is allergic.
- Our team keeps losing, and everyone is blaming each other.
- I promised to go to two different things at the same time.
- My younger cousin always wants to join in when my friends come round.
- My little brother is scared of the dark and keeps waking everyone up.
- Grandma lives far away and says she feels a bit lonely.
Family problems to solve together
- Everyone wants a different dinner on Friday night.
- The weekends are so busy that we never do anything fun together.
- Phones keep creeping onto the dinner table.
- Bedtime turns into a long negotiation every single night.
- The car journey to see the cousins feels endless.
- Nobody wants to do the washing up.
- Everyone talks at once at dinner, and the quiet ones never get a turn.
- We can never agree on which game to play on games night.
Tips for a great problem squad
- Let the child say the problem. The grown-up version ("you're disorganised") is rarely the child's version ("I can't find my things").
- Warm up with a funny one. A silly problem first gets the ideas flowing before you try a real one.
- Ban "that won't work" until step 3. Judging too early stops the ideas from coming.
- Keep real problems small at the table. Bigger worries deserve a quiet moment, just the two of you.
- Adapt by age. Ages 4 to 6 can choose between two ideas; ages 9 to 11 can weigh pros and cons and plan the steps.
Want more practice? Try The little inventors, where a problem becomes an invention, or read our tips on siblings fighting at the dinner table.
Frequently asked questions
What are problem solving scenarios for kids?
They are short, everyday situations a child can think through out loud: lost socks, a forgotten PE kit, two friends who want to be captain. Talking them through gives children practice at finding several ideas and choosing one.
What are the steps of problem solving for kids?
A simple method has four steps: say the problem in one sentence, find three ideas without judging them, choose the one that works and is kind, then try it and check back. Practise on funny problems first, then on real ones.
What is a good problem solving activity for a family?
Pick a small problem the whole family shares, like shoes piling up by the door, and solve it together at dinner: everyone suggests an idea, you choose one, and you check a week later whether it worked.