How to teach teens open-mindedness: the art of saying "good point"

Being open-minded doesn't mean having no opinions. It means being able to hear a good argument and say so, even in the middle of a disagreement. This challenge asks a teen to say "I hadn't thought of that" once when someone makes a good point, and it works best when parents say it too.

Why "good point" matters

Teens are building their opinions, and it is natural to defend them hard. But someone who can never admit a good point ends up in arguments that go round in circles. Saying "good point" doesn't mean losing. It shows you are listening, and it usually makes the other person listen better in return.

This is what is sometimes called intellectual humility: knowing you might be missing something, and being curious rather than defensive about it. It helps at school, with friends and later at work. At home, it turns the dinner table into a place where minds can shift a little without anyone losing face. Teens learn it mostly by watching whether the adults around them ever do it.

How to practise it, step by step

  1. Model it first, out loud. The next time your teen makes a fair point, say "I hadn't thought of that", and mean it. Do it a few times before you offer the challenge.
  2. Offer the challenge. "Once this week, when someone makes a good point, say so, even if you still disagree overall. Take it, change it or skip it."
  3. Separate the point from the conclusion. You can admit one good point and keep your opinion: "Good point about the travel time. I still think the trip's worth it." Teens relax when they see that conceding a point isn't conceding everything.
  4. Make it safe to say. Nobody pounces with "So you admit I'm right!" A good point acknowledged is a moment to move on, not a win to celebrate.
  5. Ask what shifted. At the end of the meal: "Did anything tonight make you think differently, even a little?" Parents answer too, honestly.
  6. Notice it when it happens. "You said 'fair point' to your sister earlier. That's not easy in the middle of a debate." Specific notice makes it more likely to happen again.

Open-minded is not the same as giving in

Some parents worry that teaching a teen to say "good point" makes them easier to push around. It doesn't have to, if the habit is taught well. The question to practise is: "Did the argument get better, or just louder?" Changing your mind because someone gave a better reason is open-mindedness. Changing it because a group kept insisting, or because someone made you feel silly, is something else.

Talk about that difference at the table, with light examples. A friend who explains why a film is worth watching has given a reason; a friend who just keeps repeating "everyone's seen it" hasn't. A teen who can tell the two apart can be open to good arguments and still hold firm against pressure, which is exactly the balance we want.

By age

Ages 12–14

For younger teens, admitting a good point can feel like losing, especially with brothers and sisters watching. Start with silly debates where nothing is at stake: the best superpower, the worst pizza topping, the most useless invention. Give them one short phrase that doesn't feel embarrassing, such as "Fair point." When they use it, notice it lightly rather than making a big deal of it.

Ages 15–17

Older teens can handle weightier subjects: school choices, plans for the future, the way the family does things. Challenge them to name the best argument on the other side before giving their own. They also watch closely whether parents ever change their minds, so let them see it happen: "You've convinced me. Let's try it your way." Nothing teaches open-mindedness like an adult who visibly practises it.

What to say

For the teen:

  • "Huh, I hadn't thought of that."
  • "Fair point. I still see it differently, though."
  • "OK, that's a better argument than mine."
  • "You've got me there."
  • "I didn't know that. Where did you hear it?"
  • "That changes things a bit for me."
  • "I'll give you that one."
  • "I was wrong about that part, to be fair."
  • "Say that again? I want to think about it."

For parents:

  • "That's a strong point. I need to rethink."
  • "You've changed my mind on this one."
  • "I can't argue with that, actually."
  • "Let me sit with that before I answer."
  • "What's the best argument against your own view?"
  • "Saying 'good point' in the middle of an argument takes guts. Nicely done."
  • "Did anyone hear something tonight that made them think?"

Games to practise it

  • Change my mind: one person defends an opinion; the others repeat it accurately before trying to shift it, and anyone may say "you've moved me a bit".
  • Switch sides: arguing the opposite view is the fastest way to find the good points in it.
  • Press conference: a spokesperson announces an unpopular decision and has to answer the actual question, including admitting where a reporter has a point.
  • Family debate club: mixed teams of grown-ups and kids; at the end, each team names the other side's best argument.

Common mistakes

  • Gloating when they concede. "Ha, so I was right!" makes it very unlikely they will admit a good point again.
  • Never conceding yourself. If adults never say "good point", teens learn that admitting one is for the losing side.
  • Confusing open-minded with having no opinion. The goal is to keep your views and stay curious, not to agree with everyone.
  • Forcing it. A "good point" said through gritted teeth because of the challenge isn't the habit; waiting for a genuine one is fine.
  • Only practising on serious topics. Light debates are where the phrase becomes natural; save the weighty ones for later.

Pair this challenge with Disagree without getting angry and The echo, or play Change my mind to practise listening before answering.

Frequently asked questions

How do you teach a teenager to be open-minded?

Model it: say "good point" or "I hadn't thought of that" when your teen makes a fair argument, and let them see you change your mind sometimes. Practise on light debates at dinner, where admitting a point costs nothing.

What is intellectual humility for teens?

It is accepting that you might be missing something: listening to other views, admitting a good point and changing your mind when an argument is better. It doesn't mean giving up your opinions.

How do I get my teenager to admit they are wrong?

Start smaller: instead of asking them to admit they are wrong, invite them to name one good point on the other side. Make it safe by never gloating, and admit your own mistakes out loud.

The challenge in Kalmdix

Once, say "I hadn't thought of that" when someone makes a good point.

How Kalmdix helps

Kalmdix announces the challenge lightly, never as a rule or a lesson, and the teen may decline or change it. It runs over five meals; the results are shown after the meal.

More in Teen challenges

Games · Habits · Blog · Pricing · Sign in

Terms · Privacy